Hack Attack Week Nine: Slow Shawneeki Sucks at the Pocketbook
By weekend hacker
Course: Shawneeki Golf Club
Date: Thursday, 30th June, 2008
Weather: Hot and humid, with a prolonged rain shower, 25C.
Tees used: Blue (6307 yards) Rating 70.0 Slope 130
Score Shot: 84 – not a good day at the office!
Tee time intervals: 9 minutes
Time taken: 3 hours, 45 minutes
The Course
Quality of service:
The people in the pro shop and clubhouse were very friendly so I’ve no complaints at all. Actually, the course was very quiet (a sign of the times?) and I didn’t see a beverage cart all day.
Goat Track or Weekend in Paradise:
While I hesitate to call it a goat track, Shawneeki certainly would never be my idea of a weekend in paradise. There’s little or no variety and I can’t think of a good risk/reward hole at all.
How the rock rolls:
The rock rolls slowly at Shawneeki, at least it did on the day I was there. The surfaces were very patchy but the ball rolled quite smoothly – I just couldn’t hit it hard enough to reach the hole.
Conditioning:
Average and mediocre were the words that kept springing to mind as I played Shawneeki. There’s nothing drastically wrong, but there’s nothing worth writing home about either. Maybe it’s because of the wet weather that the fairways seemed a little long and the first cut a little deeper than I expected. While it’s nothing to affect play, the edges of the bunkers weren’t cut sharply – the whole place just looked a bit untidy.
Making the Cut:
I find it hard to get excited about Shawneeki. While there are no real Mickey Mouse holes, there’s nothing memorable either. I don’t want to be overly critical of a relatively low budget golf course, but I found it quite boring. I was unable to find any online information about the course architect, so I presume it wasn’t a well known name in golfing circles.
Hacker’s Highlights:
Maybe in an effort to put some variety into the golf course, there is a very unusual change being made to the 15th hole. A large man made pond has been constructed in the middle of the fairway about 240 yards from the Blue tee blocks and about 215 from the Whites. While Bubba Watson might be able to make the 300 yard carry to the other side, mere mortals are forced to lay up and hit an approach shot from around 175 yards. There is a tiny sliver of fairway on either side of the pond, so I suppose the more adventurous among us could still take their chances with a driver!
They’re also making changes to the last hole, but this time slightly more conventional and more pleasing to the eye. The hole is a slight dogleg to the left and a well positioned tee shot is required to leave a short iron approach over water to a new slightly undulating green surrounded by grass mounds. Saving the best for last?
Hit To Your Pocketbook:
I paid 57 dollars to walk. It’s an easy walk, with no major elevation changes and no long hikes between greens and tees.
Hacking Away: 70%
Shawneeki currently isn’t worth any more than 40 bucks of this hacker’s money.
(Final rating is an indication of what the course is worth versus the green fee charged. According to the Hacker, a poor course could be worth less than the green fee charged, while a strong course that offers value might actually be underpriced.)
- Shawneeki’s Closer: Slow Greens and Uninspired Layout
- Shawneeki’s 13th
- The 15th at Shawneeki
- Shawneeki’s opener











October 14th, 2008 at 10:14 pm
Played the Course in September, it was fantastic! The Greens were slick, and in good shape. I played there a lot a few years ago, but with some recent re-location with work I haven’t been back in a few years, and it is great!
The 15th needs some time to grow in, but will be a nice hole. I was talking with the Head Pro about the reno’s, and he was saying it was to accommodate a new practice facility, and he seemed very excited about it. The designer is Dave Moote. Who I just searched online.
mootegolfarchitects.com
Not a bad resume.
Anyway, I love the course, it’s an old course, with improvements happening still. I will be back!!
March 9th, 2009 at 9:36 am
While I agree with many of the comments I cannot agree with the overall assessment.
In general not a very inspiring course but at the same time play it from the tips and it is more challenge than you could ask for.
I have found the greens to be in great shape and normally quite fast. I think on your day the greens were slow due to the wet weather.
By suggesting this is a course worthy of a $40 green fee I am left wondering what courses you may be comparing it to, or are you stating that overall, green fees in the GTA are too high (who can argue that). What course in the GTA or the Newmarket area currently charges $40. This is a superior course to Cardinal, and thus charges more. It is inferior to Silver Lakes and thus charges less. Personally I think $57 is more than reasonable.
March 9th, 2009 at 9:58 am
My review of Shawneeki was a fair reflection of the course on that particular day. I was disappointed (and surprised) at the condition of the greens as the quality of the putting surfaces had been the highlight of my previous visits there.
Hopefully, it was just a blip, but the course was untidy when I was there and in my view, not good value for money.
With the current economic situation, it will be interesting to see the effects on the golf industry. Personally, I think people will happily spend their limited dollars playing golf and most courses will do okay, but the retail side will suffer as no-one really “needs” a new set of clubs every year.